Cream Iof Mushroom and Beef Gravy Roast
Sort by: Most Helpful
Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest
08/16/2012
Excellent! My family and I absolutely loved this and it has become a regular menu item ay our house.
10/13/2012
Really great and easy. I usually use red wine, but liked it very much with sherry for a change (not cooking sherry, buy a decent brand, then you can have some for yourself). The meat and the gravy is excellent!
10/12/2012
This is absolutely a terrific recipe!!!! So simple and very very delicious just as it is! Thanks for sharing!
02/09/2013
Not bad, liked the simplicity but it needed help to make it a 5 star for me. Added fresh chopped mushrooms, onions, rosemary, thyme, lots of pepper, and worshesterchire to add flavor, also cooked some vegitables right in the crock second time around was good
10/29/2012
Excellent roast beef recipe and SO easy. The only thing I did differently was quickly browned my chuck roast on all sides in a little olive oil before placing in crockpot. Since we are mushrooms lovers, I sautéed some fresh mushrooms in the same pan and added them as well.
03/06/2013
Absolutely simple & delicious! Patted the chuck roast down with flour on both sides before placing it in the crockpot. This eliminated having to thicken the gravy at the end. Perfect!
12/21/2012
I cooked this recipe according to directions and it was divine. This recipe was a big hit with my husband who was so impressed he immediately posted a picture on his Facebook labeled "My Wife has outdone herself again". If he only knew how simple it was. Thanks for sharing. I will be making this again.
09/04/2012
Very good recipe. The meat was very tender and the gravy was delicioius. Will definately make again many times.
10/23/2012
We made this last night---and it was soooooooo good!! I added some more mushrooms to the mix (1 jar drained) and about an hour before serving, I added some diluted cornstarch to thicken the gravy. As sides we had garlic mashed potatoes and sauteed garlic green beans. We will certainly be making this again!
11/17/2013
So heres the deal....I don't own a crock pot, because my hubby hates them he thinks the house is going to burn down and food comes out mushy. So I had to improvise because the ingredients looked good. I cooked at 350 for 2 hours in the oven with all ingredients and added fresh onion and garlic and used 1/2 of the onion soup mix as a rub. What I will do differently is add the soup and broth 3/4 to half way through because my roast came out well done on the bottom and med rare on the top, which kind of worked out for us because he likes well done and I like rare. We'll see next time, will definitely make again.
10/31/2012
I made this exactly as the recipe described, but was short on time, so I cooked it on high for 4 hours and it turned out out GREAT!! My oldest son actually huged me and thanked me. He went back for a 3rd helping. I added alittle cornstartch to the gravy and it was wonderful. A definite keeper!
01/24/2013
LOVE LOVE LOVE!!! I made this and my whole picky eater family loved it! Used the left overs and had a open faced roast sandwich for lunch the next day. Thanks for the recipe!! Have already shared it with friends and family. SOOO Easy to make!!
01/26/2013
Made this today--did not use Sherry (forgot to buy it). Also used about a tsp. of corn starch to thicken after it had cooked. Cooked it 8 hours on low, it was FANTASTIC!!! I was kind of nervous about making a roast but it was so easy. This is one of my new favorite meals. My hubby, son, and I all really loved it. It is definitely going in our 'must make again' box!!
01/23/2013
Super easy and delicious. I made this for myself and a friend and it was perfect. She couldn't stop complimenting it, and took all of the leftovers home. I did add some cornstarch to the gravy though.
01/28/2013
My family loved this recipe. I followed it exactly, except I used dry white wine instead of sherry. I served it with mashed potatoes and green beans.
01/08/2013
This was amazing! I made it today and my entire family loved it, which is not easy to do! I prepared it without the Sherry, simply because I forgot to get some. It was delicious and the gravy was so good.
01/27/2013
Amazingly flavorful. Thank you!
03/25/2013
This was a VERY delicious recipe. I didnt change a thing. Very easy to make. LOVE IT!!!!!
03/17/2013
I made the recipe exactly as and it turned out very good. I put it on high the last hour and that thickened up the gravy. Next time I am going to add carrots and canned mushrooms.
02/13/2013
This is a full proof recipe.I had never made beef roast in the slow cooker until I tried this wonderful recipe for my Christmas day party. It was the first thing that disappeared from the table. The meat was so soft and flavourful. The only thing that I may try next time is to only add i can of mushroom soup instead of 2....I think it should be enough. Even my picky 7 year old daughter thought it was yummy!
01/06/2013
Fantastic! Loved by the kids and the grandparents. Made a LOT of gravy, so I might half that next time or re-use on a second roast. I used a 4 lb roast and browned it first, but otherwise followed exactly. As an alternative to mashed potatos, I served it with the roasted "Beets n Sweets" recipe on this site (with regular potatos added). The gravy meshed really well the roasted potatos and vegies. An absolute keeper!
10/18/2018
The best! The meat comes out perfect and the gravy is amazing. Have tried to add potatoes/carrots/celery to the pot but have found this hinders how delicious the gravy is so I don't add any veggies directly to the pot anymore.
01/10/2013
AMAZING!! Beef was so tender. Gravy just needed a little thickening up and it was sooooo good! Hubby said it was stew on a plate (I served with potatoes and carrots) and that was a good thing. Thanks for the recipe.**update**Brother-in-law had leftovers. Commented that this was the best gravy he'd ever had and I believe the word heaven was used :)
12/14/2014
Very good the only change I made was making my own cream of mushroom soup and adding it to the crock pot with the rest of the ingredients .. will make again
07/08/2013
Thus recipe was kind of salty. I used low sodium soup but the gravy was still salty. If I make it again I will make the cream of mushroom soup myself. Over all the meat was great! My husband really liked it.
06/18/2013
is there any kind of substitude for the sherry or wine----want to make it but without the sherry or wine
03/06/2013
My whole family loved this. I served it on top of mashed potatoes.
03/05/2018
Absolutely perfect! Served with Garlic mashed potatoes. Will definitely serve this on a regular basis.
10/18/2019
After years of dry, tasteless roast beef I had almost given up before finding this recipe! It immediately became a family favorite! Such an easy, flavorful meal to make on days when we will be out for awhile! One of the first few times I made it i realized I only had a single can of cream of mushroom soup so i substituted a can of golden mushroom soup for the 2nd can. We liked it and have made it that way since. Both ways are great!
02/11/2019
Easy and delish! Can't wait for tomorrow's leftovers.
05/26/2018
Excellent. My family can't wait for me to prepare it again!
02/01/2019
This was a very easy recipe. I added carrots and red potatoes to the crockpot. It was delicious!
03/02/2013
fantastic
02/24/2018
This turned out just about perfect. I added baby red potatoes, carrots, pearl onions (frozen) and celery about 2.5 hours from the end. Cooked for 10 hours. I neglected to trim the excess fat off the exterior of the chuck roast. Next time I will, there's plenty of fat marbled throughout. Also just plain forgot the sherry. Didn't miss it but will add it next time. Will definitely make this again.
04/11/2013
mine turned out a little dry but otherwise was good
10/18/2013
My family loved this recipe. I believe in following the recipes that people post as they are, and this recipe wasn't lacking a thing.
09/21/2019
Absolutely love this recipe! My family loves it and my son begs for it when he's on leave from the Army! The only thing I add is a little thickening to the gravy.
06/06/2018
This is great! You start it in the morning before work, then come home to a great meal. We're having it again tonight.
04/19/2019
I made this as written. Very tasty. It does make a lot of gravy. I will make this again. Thank you for sharing!
03/12/2013
So yummy! I have made this twice now- once without the Sherry because I didn't have any on hand and once with; my husband and I didn't notice a difference. I served this with garlic mashed potatoes and brown sugar glazed carrots. So easy!
05/20/2017
I made this and I hate when people change the recipe and review it but I didn't have sherry and I did skip that. It was delicious and perhaps the simplest main dish I've made. I will make again and again.
01/28/2014
I was looking for a nice and easy beef and gravy recipe and had all of the ingredients on hand so decided to make this. I am not a fan of the soup mix packets since they're so salty, so I just made my own using a few simple ingredients. I added a handful of chopped mushrooms about halfway through cooking time. I halved the recipe. It did not need to cook on low the same amount of time. Probably about 6 hours. The gravy was a bit thin but the dish was altogether amazing! I was very happy with how delicious it turned out and how simple it was to throw together.
03/25/2013
Yum!
11/18/2017
I (almost) made it as is. I didn't have sherry so left that out, and added large chunks of Yukon Gold potatoes and carrots (~ 1.5 - 2" pieces) to the bottom of the crock because I love roasted root veggies and wanted to impart the roast flavor to them as well. Otherwise I followed the recipe and it was very tasty! The gravy was very flavorful and neither too thin or too thick. Next time I will play with other seasonings and veggies to customize to my taste preferences. It's a very good recipe to start with and then tweak it to make it your own.
10/20/2014
Fantastic! I used a Sirloin Tip Roast instead of Chuck roast, and the meat was falling apart. Pair it with homemade mashed potatoes, and I'm looking forward to leftovers tonight!
07/26/2015
One can of mushroom soup was enough. Made plenty of delicious sauce, which I thickened up with a little cornstarch/water in a pan.
03/21/2016
It was delicious! I added potatoes and mini carrots. Everyone loved it.
10/10/2013
This was awesome! Didn't change anything just added a little rosemary and pepper and some onions. Delicious.
08/01/2016
I made exactly as directed. It was quite tasty. But if you like your beef anyway other than very well done, I would suggest one of the following. Start with a frozen piece of beef or reduce the cooking time. It was very flavorful and tender but also very well done. Mine reached an internal temp of 191 F in 3.5 hours on low so I removed it from the crock pot at that point sliced it and we ate. I use my crock pot at least once a week. I do not usually have temperature issues with it. The beef was 2.87 lbs. before cooking. So my best suggestion is to be mindful of the cooking time because you will probably need to adjust it. Otherwise it was very good and there were no leftovers !
02/19/2015
Excellent way to roast a beef and have a great gravy ready at the same time! I do flour beef and braise it in a Ninja, then slow cook per recipe. I like to serve it with mashed potatoes, steamed green beans and cold apple sauce. This deserves ten stars, thank you so much for the recipe!
02/02/2013
My husband and I enjoyed this. The flavor was great. I put this in the slow cooker on high for about 5 hours. I didn't think it was particularly tender. It certainly wasn't bad, but I expected so much more based on the other reviews.
04/30/2017
This was amazing! I added chopped fresh onions to the meat as my husband loves onions.
01/20/2016
I used a little more Sherry but otherwise followed the recipe as written. It was divine!
11/18/2014
This recipes makes fantastic gravy....yum!
05/11/2017
Yes I will make this again. The meat was very tender and the gravy had good flavor. Easy prep makes it all the better
04/01/2014
blah mushrooms!
11/20/2014
My husband, my son and I had this for supper. WOW!!! I used a beef blade roast and it just fell apart. First, I seared the roast in a frying pan. After placing the roast in the slow cooker, I added a glass of water to the brownings and scraped them off off the pan. I used the water and Brownings instead of regular beef broth. I mixed the two cans of mushroom soup with two cans of water. I then added the dry onion soup mix to the other soup and mixed it together.. I then poured the soup and browning mixes onto the roast. I did not use sherry or wine or any substitutes for them. Once I got the slow cooker warmed and the roast to start cooking, I added a small pinch of each Rosemary and thyme. I will definitely make it again.
04/12/2016
one of the best slow cookers roast
10/30/2017
Turned out really great! Instead of using the sherry I used red wine and my husband raved about it for days and loved the leftovers.
08/15/2019
Almost as good as my favorite restaurant But excellent overall. Followed recipe to the tee. Next time, will add some sour cream to the gravy just to see if it will be closer to my favorite restaurant.
03/20/2013
I like this but there's a fine line with the roast being over done. I add mushrooms to the gravy too!
11/09/2012
This was the BEST pot roast I have ever eaten! I think the secret is that there is plenty of gravy, which keeps the meat moist. It was falling apart after 8 hours, super tender! I will definitely make this again. The best part is that you can throw this together before you go to work, it's so easy.
10/25/2015
It was good. Loved the flavor, but I agree with some of the other reviews about adding extra items. I put in fresh mushrooms, carrots and potato. Next time I will add, garlic and some herbs.
11/28/2019
I didn't have cream of mushroom so i used cream of potatoes and added fresh mushrooms. Yummm!!!
02/09/2015
Whole family enjoyed. Served with mashed potatos and green beans. Great recipe for busy working mom's.
11/13/2017
Fantastic! I've never been a big fan or pot roast but this one is definitely a winner. To say it was fork tender would be a gross understatement. Served open face sandwich style with mashed potatoes just like Mom used to make...only better. ;)
09/07/2016
The roast beef recipe I have been looking for! Made exactly as directed but added fresh mushrooms the last hour because we LOVE mushrooms. Served over egg noodles but would be great with potatoes and carrots too. I don't think I'll ever make roast beef any other way.
08/22/2016
This is a keeper. I used beef consomme since I didn't have broth. Will definitely use this recipe over and over again.
12/11/2016
I didn't add the sherry and I made beef broth from a beef base
10/30/2014
I used less of the onion soup mixture than requested in the recipe, and I seared the meat first and deglazed the pan with the beef broth for added flavor. It was an easy and delicious. I'll be making this again soon. Thanks for sharing!
11/02/2020
Made this for my daughter's family. They loved it. I also added some Worchester sauce and some added spices. Everybody loved it!
12/25/2016
Added some fresh garlic cloves chopped, and let roast/mixture marinate overnight
02/10/2017
Delicious. Used "better than bouillion " for the beef stock. Best gravy ever!
06/08/2014
I cooked this last night (in lieu of the stroganoff) and it came out WONDERFULLY! Even though I didn't have beef broth (just used water), the gravy was still #BOMBdotCom About an hour before it was done, I added stew veggies (carrots, potatos, celery, lima bean, pees, etc)
01/22/2018
RIDICULOUSLY good and EASY! Only change I made was to dredge the roast in flour before adding to the crockpot and adding a spoonful of cornstarch to the gravy an hour before serving. Soooooo wonderful. My dad couldn't get over how tender the meat was!
01/23/2013
This was great! Used red wine instead of Sherry and added mushrooms and carrots to the crock pot as well. Did put some cornstarch in the gravy at the end to thicken it up like some of the other folks, and it turned out just perfect! Paired this with garlic mashed and we all loved it!
12/02/2019
made according the recipe (but with smaller roast - half the size) and adjusted other ingredients accordingly. Gravy was delicious - next time will use a larger roast so we have more leftover!
11/09/2015
I browned the roast first with some onions. It was yummy.
09/18/2017
This was one of my favorite dinners I've made. everything was great! I added a little bit of red wine in the gravy mixture. I also took the beef out of the Crock-Pot when it was finished and broiled it for 7 minutes just to crisp up the edges. I'll definitely be making it again!
Source: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/222637/roast-beef-and-gravy/
0 Response to "Cream Iof Mushroom and Beef Gravy Roast"
Post a Comment